Transcript for Ali Abu Awwad and Robi Damelin on Nonviolence as The Path to Freedom for Palestinians and Israelis
SPEAKER_00
00:00 - 10:09
Hi everyone, I'm Renee Brown and this is unlocking us. So before we jump into the podcast today, I want to give you a little bit of context about kind of what's going on and what we're doing. I came back from the holiday. I took a couple of extra weeks. Many of you know that my mom passed away on Christmas day after a long and awful dementia journey. And I've also been off social for I think maybe a year. So I came back, got back on social. And plan to release kind of new podcasts with unlocking us and dare to lead this spring. One of the things that happened when I got back on social is a collision of me wanting to address what's happening in Israel and Palestine and a call for me to do that in a really reasonable call because I share my beliefs and thoughts about these kind of issues all the time, both globally and domestically. So I think it was a really reasonable Question about where's your voice on this? So I wrote a piece and I posted on the website and the reactions were swift and there were some people that were supportive and thank you and there were a lot of people who thought, man, this is a huge disappointment. you missed a lot of things that you should have gotten right here. And so I've spent the last, this was probably a week and a day ago, maybe eight or nine days ago, we left comments open for a week. I just want to say for the people who commented on the website, we did not leave social media open, we just did the website because we have a new platform on the website. The comments were smart, exacting, challenging, critical, and passioned, painful. And so I've spent the last eight or nine days reading every single comment. Talking and probably more importantly, talking directly with friends whose opinions are completely different than mine and people who challenge me in big ways. And a lot of learning, a lot of unlearning and a lot of clarity about what I actually do believe and what I don't believe. And so I asked our new podcast partners at Vox if we could hold on the new podcast launch. And if they would be willing to let me do three podcasts on these issues, commercial free, no monetization, no revenue tied to them. And they said absolutely, this is important, do it. And so in addition to a follow up essay on brnebron.com, I'm releasing three podcasts one today, one tomorrow and one Friday. And I'm going to talk to activists on the ground in Israel and Palestine. I'm going to talk to Jewish Israeli activist, Palestinian Israeli activist, and I had an amazing conversation with a Middle East analyst who studies Palestine and mostly really looks at US involvement in not only failed attempts at peace brokering, but US involvement with Israel and Palestine. And so I have learned a ton and I'm continuing to learn and I want to give you the context of what these next three podcasts are going to be like. So let me jump in a little bit and tell you about the episode today. I'm talking to Tugest, Robbie Damlin and Ali Abu Awad. And let me just tell you about each of them. So Robbie was born and raised in a progressive family in South Africa during a part-time. Her family was politically active in the anti-apartite movement. Her uncle defended Nelson Mandela during the 1956 trees in trial. The pressure from the South African authorities due to Damlan's vocal opposition to apartheid led her to moving to Israel in her 20s as of all interior during the six day war in June of 1967. The war ended soon after she arrived, she settled into Kabat's attending a Hebrew program to learn the language, and soon after that she got married and had two sons. David and Iran. She worked at the Jerusalem Post, then with immigrants, and then after her divorce, she relocated to Tel Aviv where she ran a public relations company. Damlan Sun David was in the Israeli Army reserves and was stationed at the Ophra checkpoint. He was killed by a Palestinian sniper on the 3rd of March 20-02 at the age of 28. Robby is the spokesperson and director of the international relations for the parents circle family forum. It's a grassroots organization made up of hundreds of bereaved Israeli and Palestinian families working together for reconciliation to in the occupation and for peace and just a disclosure. I think it's helpful context. How I met Robby and also the I guess the birthplace of my beliefs around peacemaking. I met Robbie at a Middle East Peace Conference in 2007. I was asked to facilitate the panel with Palestinian and Israeli bereaved family members. And this is when I was introduced to the work of the parent circle family forum. And it very much informed my ideas and my beliefs about. the ability to hold space for humanity across polarizing ideas and how we can hold people accountable for injustice while at the same time not diminishing their humanity as Mother Sun's sister's brothers. And so that's Robbie. Our other guest is Ali Abu Awad. Ali was raised in a politically active refugee family. He's Palestinian. As a young child, Ali witnessed Israeli agents beat and humiliate his mother for her political activism. She was very involved in the Palestinian Liberation Organization. Seeing his mother subjected to this and his daily life under occupation, stirred the inverse of resistance within him and during the first Intafada, Ali was arrested by Israel for his leadership in the resistance and for refusing to supply information against his mom who'd also been arrested. With the Oslo Accords in 1993, Ali was released and began serving in the newly created Palestinian Authority Security Forces. But Ali quickly became disillusioned with the political process being forced to arrest his fellow Palestinians for their continued resistance to Israel, despite the pay's ability to guarantee the rights of citizenship due to Israel's ongoing occupation. In 2003, years after his resignation from the Palestinian Authority Security Force, Ali was shot by a settler while he was changing a tire on a West Bank road. Sent a Saudi Arabia for treatment. He received there the news that would change his life forever. And Israeli soldier had murdered his beloved brother, Yusuf, shot at point blank range at the entrance to his hometown in the West Bank. It was after this loss that Ali's mother began inviting bereaved Israeli families from the parent circle into their home. They believe there had been enough bloodshed. She realized that she wanted to save her other children and those meetings changed the trajectory of Ali's life. From 2002 to 2009, Abu Awad toured the world as the Palestinian spokesperson for the parent circle, bereaved family forum. And actually, you'll see, and you'll listen in here, I think, in this interview, that a lot of the work he did was with Robbie. They shared the mutual grief and understanding built between Palestinians and Israelis who've lost people to this conflict. His life and work were featured during that time during two award winning films and counterpoint in forbidden childhood. In 2016, he had fully turned his activism to the priority of developing a mass independent movement on the ground of Palestinian's organizing Palestinians to take nonviolent responsibility for self-development and forging a path to in the occupation. That movement, talking here, which means change, is dedicated to fostering Palestinian national nonviolent identity and action through which communities, leaders and organizations come together to address social development needs and work in the occupation. As an activist, Ali believes that nonviolence is the only path forward to freedom for both Palestinians and Israelis. In 2023, Ali was awarded both the Indira Gandhi Peace Prize and the Luxembourg Peace Prize. I'm going to jump right into the conversation with Robbie and Ali. What an honor. To have both of you on the podcast, I'm so deeply grateful for the work you're doing. I'm so hungry to learn more about it and hungry to learn what support looks like for your vision. So let me just start by saying thank you for being here. Thank you for inviting us. We always start the podcast the same way, which is asking our guests to tell us their story. we believe that stories and narratives give power to understanding each other. So, Robbie, would you like to start and tell us your story?
SPEAKER_01
10:09 - 18:52
Probably anybody will notice within a minute that my life started in South Africa. But I've been in Israel since 1967. I think the main part of my story is the loss, actually. I mean, I could tell you a lot of naughty stories along the line, but I think When the army came to tell me that David had been killed by a Palestinian sniper, one of the first things that I said was, you can't kill anybody in the name of my child. So it was very clear somewhere along the line that I was going to do something Something to prevent other mothers from experiencing this pain, and it didn't matter which mothers are seeing you noise lately. I understood almost immediately that my life would take a completely new direction. It's your life before and your life after. And what do you do with all of this pain? And for me, sort of almost connecting to today, I see my behavior after the symptoms of October is very similar. To what happened to me after David was killed, I had this immediate urge or desire or mania almost to change the world. And so, something like three months after David was killed, I found my salted, huge demonstration thing that we had to get out of dark and dark territories. And what was so extraordinary, I recognized that after loss, there's no fear. I have no fear, you can actually put me wherever you like, and I don't care, I will talk, and I won't say what's in my heart. So what happens is I never prepare anything. And after I spoke at this huge demonstration, the parent circle found me and invited me to come to a weekend in East Jerusalem with Palestinian and Israeli families who'd all lost an immediate family member. And I can remember sitting around the table and looking into the eyes of the Palestinian, particularly the mothers and realizing that we shared the same thing, and that was like almost the beginning. of what I was going to be doing, because I understood that if we stood on the stage and spoke in the same voice, reconciliation and nonviolence, ensuring that would be an extraordinary example for anybody else in the world. And that we can change my whole life. My kids, my office, started to travel all around the world and I thought it was amazingly important. and could speak English, and I was very pleased with myself. I spoke wherever, to get all the Palestinian partner wherever I was invited. Concerts, hip-hop concerts, I don't know, Congress, all kinds of extraordinary places that who would have believed. And one night, when I was heard, I was sitting next to my computer, and there was a knock on my door. And I opened the door and it was three soldiers standing there. And when there three soldiers that cannot remain one thing, so I kept standing the door in their face and they kept knocking. And I thought if I didn't send my other child, that's for end I can't. And then they eventually I opened the door and they said, we can't return you that we caught the man who killed Edward. That's when it became difficult because you can go around the world and you could talk about peace and love and read that poetry as must angels do. Or, you know, what was I to do now to remain in some form of integrity? And actually, I need to connect it here to this part of my story who I was wondering around for months, not sleeping. And one morning he said, we were right, they were later to the parents, which is what I did. And in the later, I told him about the parent circle. We are now 700 families. Of course, Palestinian and Israeli have all lost an immediate family member. And I told him about David, my son. He was a student at Tel Aviv University studying for his masters in philosophy of education. And he was part of the peace movement. He also was part of the student uprising. I can't imagine where I got that from. And he played the French horn, which I deserve a make-over for. And he was this extraordinarily lovely kid who used to cook with me and drink with me and we had so much fun together. And I told him that I thought we should meet because we heard that to our children and grandchildren. So early, and probably freely in letter on, together with Nadua, a Palestinian former group, delivered the letter to the family. You can imagine how shocked they were. I immediately, not being the most patient character in the Middle East, imagine that there will be a letter the next day. Well, of course, that didn't happen. and it took three years and I got this message over a website to say that I'm crazy and I should stay away from these family and that he can't, this is from the sniper, he killed 10 people to free Palestine. But I mean, and this is something also connected with the war now, is I want to talk about understanding why people do things. From his parents, I understood that when it was a small child, he had seen his uncle violently killed by the Israeli army. And he lost two uncles in the second uprising. And so, I think this was an act of revenge. And so, what happened is when I got this later, it was like giving up being a victim. I was now free, I'm no longer contingent on what this man says. And I felt I could continue with the work, and I went off to South Africa, and we made a film, which is called One Day of the Peace, and extraordinarily, so it's also very relevant today. There's a soldier called Gilad Shant. Gina Chilit was a young Israeli soldier who was captured and picked as a hostage in Gaza for ideas. And I said then that they should free the prisoners, even if it were bring Gina Chilit back and sent me to treat the man who killed my child. Of course, I cannot speak for other parents. I can only speak in my own voice. And I went to the television and and I said that openly and you can imagine how popular that made me. But I thought it was important. And so I actually recently in the war now, I just wrote an update to say, please free this man if that's going to bring even more wine of the hostages back. So everything is kind of tied up one thing to the other. And in South Africa, I made the extraordinary woman When I was June 3, and she'd lost her daughter and she'd gone to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and told the people who killed her daughter, I forgive you. And I wanted to understand what the meaning of forgiveness. You know, everywhere I talk, everybody I ask, what do you mean when you say you forgive? Everybody comes up with a different answer. And I went to Nietzsche and we became sisters immediately, which happens with all bereaved mothers. And she said, forgiving is giving up your just right to revenge. And then I met the man who actually sent the people to kill her daughter. And he, I thought I'm going to make this monster, and here comes this man who says, by her forgiving me, she released me from my inhumanity. I thought that was an extraordinary statement. And I came back to Israel and tried to meet the sniper. This is a long story. But the law here actually says that he has to ask to meet me. So I've tried via letters and via his lawyer, but it's not working and it's really not all that important for me now. And that's where the story is, but there's so much bigger things than well be damned than now.
SPEAKER_00
18:52 - 19:04
Thank you for sharing your story with us. And I hold it very tenderly. and with a lot of love and a lot of grief. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01
19:04 - 19:10
And hope. Hope is the most important equation in peace.
SPEAKER_00
19:10 - 19:14
Ali, would you be willing to share your story with us?
SPEAKER_02
19:14 - 27:03
Well, from the human and emotional side of my story, it's not so different than Robby's story. We are the consequences of this madness. We both experienced lost, I lost my brother in the second antifat on 2000. But all of my life was about loss. I grew up as a refugee, was born to a very political family, was raised by a very political mother. And we both end up in prison in 1990. serving few years. And the first encounter with non-violent actually was in prison. When I me and my mother decided to go for a hunger strike to see each other after three years of being in prison. And we succeed. We succeed after 17 days of starvation. We succeed to see each other and that moment I fell. strength that I have never experienced before. It was not just about our success, it was about discovering something really powerful inside me. But I also discovered the blindness of my truth, because all what I felt was true, but I was blind to the most powerful think that I have never met or used before, which is my humanity. Anger was a blindness for that humanity to rise. And then I was released by Oslovi's initiative and trying to achieve and support the peace process as a leader and a son of a leader. and the process has failed for many reasons, but I think the biggest reason that politicians were not really aiming to achieve the vision of the process, because the challenges were huge. And there was no real engagement to practice what we saw on papers. On the ground, there was no different. We couldn't, we followed, couldn't see the front between peace or conflict because we couldn't achieve our freedom or independent. At the same time, Israelis still live in England's threat by suicide bombers, so the whole process has failed, including my son, Madhmy, brother, and 2000, use of. He was 31 years old, and he had an argument with a soldier in the entrance of my town, Bet, Omarnier, Hippon, that caused him his life. Then I was in a hospital in Saudi Arabia having medical treatment because I was wounded by a settler. My mother was with me. I mean, I experienced loss before but losing him was different. I was totally broken until we came back, we tried to live. But this is not the same life. These are not the same enemies. It's not the same family anymore. Many people have offered revenge to my mother. She said, no. But she couldn't give any practical step for us to do. And I think she was seeking for the art of the motherhood. which end by meeting people like Robbie and Israeli parents who have lost someone. She invited them to my home. And for me that was the other nonviolence lesson that they have to learn that the devils are not exactly devils. They are humans. They are even victims like me. Yes, we're not equal by life conditions, but we're equal by this loss that we're sharing. We're not able to share what is on the ground. That's why we're sharing just what is underground, which is the body of our loved ones. My life has changed. I mean, I have never had an opportunity to go to university or even my English came from prison. I didn't waste time there. And a good part of it came from Robbie because I tour the world with Robbie for a few years. And I have learned a lot from her, from others, and from my mother and myself. And I end up joining the parents circle with my mother, with my family. Then I went back to my people, struggling. launching, raising initiative with Israeli settlers, called routes. They remember there was time that Robbie even said we have to speak to settlers because the parents circle was very careful by any criticism you know. Then I launched this initiative, then I few years ago, I went back to my people and I said, okay, Every side has to take responsibility for their own act and to art the others. I created Tereer and Arabic change in English as a Palestinian non-violence movement that has 100% DNA Palestinian for my people to adopt non-violence as an identity. And to deal with the confusion between the two identities that we struggle with daily as a Palestinian, the identity of being part of revolution against Israel and the identity of being citizens without a state. So how can we practice low, how can we build our society without independent, but also how can we resist the occupation without causing anyone a price of his life or his dignity? This is all what the Rears about that the answer is just by nonviolence. And I think nonviolence activism for many people sounds silly, sounds weakness. And I do believe that if the war needs anger, peace needs courage, reconciliation needs truth. We have to be truthful to ourselves and to the others. And today I envision a place where these two conflicted identities can fit in a political model that each truth of them will be practiced in a fashion that will not come at the expense of anyone. And we can do that.
SPEAKER_00
27:03 - 27:51
Thank you. I can't stop thinking about David and UCF. life before they were gone and life after they were gone. Different lives. It seems to me that there's a that courage, Ali that you'd talk about that's necessary for peace. Is so often born of grief and despair? Is it a choice? Where the grief and despair is going to go? And does the level of your compassion require an experience of grief?
SPEAKER_01
27:51 - 30:48
Oh, I really hope not. Yeah, let's see too. How many people will have to die then for people to think in another way? So I think I'm the same person as I was before David was killed. Only I'm not the dictator that I was, and I'm more compassionate. And I think it was a choice. It wasn't even a conscious choice because if I said you can't do anybody in and they were much round, I wasn't looking for any kind of revenge. And I think thinking about the revenge of the war now. of the humiliation of the Israeli army. You know, of being beaten on the sit-ons of October, what that humiliation creates is revenge. And I don't have that, because if I had that sensual revenge, look, they are parents who decide who died with their children when they die. You know what, physically, but they disappear. They are parents that build libraries, monuments. I think everybody wants to do the thing that would give them some solace. And for me, because David was still into education, for me, education, or of peace, thing to be the most logical thing. You know, it's very difficult. We had a meeting the other night, and this is not all together connected with what he said, but some of the women from our group to say, look, you know, they've been so much days now on both sides that is the death that we experienced as important. Do I have the right now? Yes, it's a very interesting, I was so shocked. You know, do I have the right now to go to these people? And I know for sure that the people who gave me the last soils were the bereaved mothers, they understood. But this also appeared, you know, and I was so, I couldn't believe that they were willing to negate a loss in order to feel that they were doing the right thing. And if it happened 50 years ago, is it still not there? I think it is. You know, your life changed forever. And it's generations of suffering. I'm watching a grand children. You know, they are so involved with David. Me, are staying songs about David. You can't run away from it. And even if it happened 20 years ago, it's as painful, except you learn to live with it next to you. And what do you do with that pain? You know? And I'm sorry, got carried away.
SPEAKER_02
30:50 - 31:31
Yeah, I mean, I will add to a trophy just said, my activism is not depends on the label of bereavement. Because beyond bereavement, there is a huge machine inside me that called humanity. On the other hand, I don't think neither me or Roby or anyone else. in the balance circle or other brief balance who are joining the brief conservation process has healed their pain by joining such initiative. I think it's the opposite.
SPEAKER_01
31:31 - 33:16
But then you know, it's extraordinary. I can tell you that now People who experienced herbal terrible things on the center of October, like not was he non who's family were burnt to death. His parents were burnt to death. On the center of October, or speaking out for peace and speaking out to stop the bloodshed. And the son of Vivian Silver, who was this wonderful activist, who I was sure was a hostage, and would come back and she would lead a peace movement. Her son is joined a parent circle, nor as well as my ears, and many others. And that's an extraordinary thing, because this is like four months, you know, it's not yours. And that gives me such hope to see these people who can be the leaders in the future of the organization. We can't have all bad sight me only. We need to have new people who will hate the organization in other directions. And it's so extraordinary that they're speaking out so quickly. So that gives me an immense amount of hope, the better in community gave me a lot of hope. We spoke about hope being this important equation. You know the better ones for my unrecognized village came to the music festival and saved hundreds of kids and 19 of them were killed and some of them were taken hostage. Just think about that they didn't have a stake in this whole madness. So they are extraordinary people everywhere and that's what brings me to continue to get up in the morning to do this work.
SPEAKER_02
33:18 - 34:34
Yeah, yeah, the point is I used to say that my life was quite easier when I was one sided. I live with my story with my loss. I used to have my people and my shoulder and my brother and my heart. But after I joined the parents circle before I had another nation on the other shoulder. And I had another stories of my enemies who was supposed to be my enemies. And this is where responsibility starts. And I always have said, and I keep saying, To be a change maker, you don't need to be either bereaved or to be Mandela. You just need to be a responsible leader who think about the future, because one of the things that we suffer from, we do have politicians, but we don't have leaders. Politicians are just managers of this reality. Leaders who envision the normal future and change reality for that. And this is what we need.
SPEAKER_01
34:34 - 34:58
And we need the story tables. I am a great believer in storytelling. I've seen how that creates an emotional breakthrough. It's even the hardest of hearts. So it goes together. And I've been telling the story. I forgot all about it. Suddenly I remembered Ali about the jacket. Do you still have it?
SPEAKER_02
34:58 - 35:00
And you have.
SPEAKER_01
35:00 - 35:01
So you will tell the story.
SPEAKER_02
35:03 - 36:09
We were invited to a very important event and I don't have a jacket. And I don't like to have jackets. But Robbie came up with this jacket, this beautiful jacket. And she said, this jacket used to be for David and I want you to have it. It was hard. It was hard because I know what does it mean to let go. for Robbie to let go, but it was so strong. On the other hand, how the world is so, so weird, this man who used to be a soldier, serving a system that he's struggle also against it at the same time, but he do his duty. And now there is a Palestinian wearing his jacket. What what explanation on earth can describe that? There is no description.
SPEAKER_01
36:09 - 36:21
But this kind of a rest of the story, when you came through the checkpoint and the soldier asked you, do you remember that? Ask you where you were going and you told him. And you started?
SPEAKER_02
36:21 - 37:23
Yeah, yeah, I have many stories, especially with soldiers, because I like to speak to soldiers. And I tell the stories, I tell the stories of others, not just Palestinian Jews and others. And yeah, I mean, the power of these stories that you see the humanity of the other who is trying to blind himself to see your humanity. I always said, My weapon in nonviolence is not my humanity. It's the Jewish humanity. This is my weapon. But for me to succeed, I have to do their reflection. So nonviolence is not just to show how human you are, but to be able to see the humanity of the other. This is nonviolence. And that's hard. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
37:23 - 38:44
Everyone's pretty clear on their own humanity. Yeah, well, yeah, everyone's really clear on the depth of their own humanity. But it seems to me, and I would love to get checked on this by both of you. Can I read something, Ollie, that you said recently? You were in an interview with Amidar. And you said, we need recognition. We need to see each other. I mean, we should stop arguing each other's identities and switch to an argument about behaviors. Because occupation is a behavior. Violence is a behavior. So if we feel secure enough to change to see and recognize identities, will be able to change these behaviors that causes this ignorance of ignoring each other's identities. This is a fundamental need and foundation for a peace process. Like, everyone's so clear to me, even here in the US, the activism has a very certain narrative. Everyone's clear on their own humanity. and believes their activism depends on diminishing the humanity of others. That's what's happening here.
SPEAKER_01
38:44 - 40:36
Well, but that's terrifying. I've been to the States, quite since the war began. And listening to what's happening on the campuses, all over America, and we were invited by the World Bank. Now I thought to myself, the World Bank has to invite me because they're not talking to each other, they're taking sides. The importation of this conflict is so dangerous. It's creating hatred between Muslims and Jews. It's creating madness. What has some Jewish, it's studying a Georgetown University got to do with the decisions of Netanyahu and East Band of Hilton Glory. And so this excuse that's being used When we were at Georgetown now, there have been our mentors for many years. They are working with us on a module of dialogue meetings, which will be sent to all the campuses, all of America, with questions and answers, because I tell you, when it comes to thousands and thousands of people are turning to us, because they need some help. And so this is a way to do it, and thanks to Georgetown University, and to the teachers union, who will distribute the module, online, something we can get to a much larger audience. I couldn't believe when I was in London, what was happening? You know, I have family in London, and I have a little cousin, she's 13, and she was a star of David inside her shirt, which already tells you something. And then he went on the train and it came out of her shirt. and the guy came up to and said, die and bloody Jew. This is how the importation of our conflict is affecting the rest of the world. It's mad. If you can't be part of the solution, then please leave us alone.
SPEAKER_00
40:36 - 41:02
Ali, tell me about when Robbie says if you can't be part of the solution, one of the things that really like has moved me so deeply about time here is pro solution, pro focus on behaviors. Like it seems to me that you're the most pragmatic peacemaker that I've ever read. Like it is not rainbows and unicorns in your world.
SPEAKER_02
41:02 - 41:45
Yeah, listen, everyone speak many peace activists and organization even politicians speaks about two states solution and speak about peaceful agreement and trying to engage the war to put pressure on those or those. But for me, any piece efforts will not be successful if we don't create the environment for the agreement to happen we need that environment and those who will create that environment are not the politician it's the grassroots it's people like me and lobby and many others because when the environment is ready politicians believe me will jump before us to sign the agreement because they are not courageous as the grassroots leaders
SPEAKER_00
41:47 - 42:06
Can you all paint a picture for me about two or three qualities this environment must have? This grassroots environment? What are two or three of the foundational prerequisites for this environment of non-violence and peace?
SPEAKER_02
42:06 - 45:50
Well, first of all is to believe that non-violence is the only solution. To create that belief As Roby said, we need education. Education is so important for people to understand what nonviolence is about. Because I'm not sure that many people understand what nonviolence is. People think it's silly, it's weakness, it's giving up, it's you know. But it's the opposite, it's the art of our humanity. Hard because everyone is a human, but I'm not sure that everyone is practicing that humanity. That's the issue. Number two, the environment is about creating alternative systems to the system that we are trying to change. If anger, violence, is the answer, it creates damage. So what are the alternatives that we produce and we apply? to people be. And don't forget that we're not equal. Right. I mean, it's not about healing. It's not about transforming people harsh and mind. People also need breads on their stable. People need water resources. People need access to resources. People need the freedom of movement. People need security. People need to heal this huge pain that is endless and keep. So what alternative we change maker are offering our communities. You know, people ask me sometimes what I do, I always say I collect garbage of politicians. Because they produce garbage on communities and we change makers has to collect that garbage. And believe me, choose and Palestinians are the most human people on earth. There is enough humanity for non-violence to work. but it cannot be just through dialogue and hummus and hugs. We need practical steps on the ground for people to believe that nonviolence can be the answer. It's not about good intention. It's not even just about hope we need hope definitely, but it's more about the belief, the ideology of change. This is where we need to be. The minute that Palestinian will stop, acting as victim, the same like Jewish people here, the minute that the whole Earth will support us, both of us, and the minute that we stop investing our pain and victimhood, in one side, actions, the minute that both sides will be able to go forward. Robert said once it's the competition of suffering, We are competing over suffering. Who suffers more? By the end of the day we are all suffering and the world is very good players on that because the world is creating more divide. and it needs us to go all over the world to explain that, stop, stop, be pro solution because, however you are supporting, he's not taking over the other side. Jews and Muslims, Christian, Palestinian, Arabs are not going to disappear. It's a fact. So how do you manage it? How do we envision solution? How do we stop talking about the typical solution for two state, one state, and jump to practical solution that will allow everyone to practice their identity without causing the other a price of their dignity and their identity? That's a big question.
SPEAKER_01
45:50 - 48:12
But I also think that you need to prepare people. for reconciliation, because it's the robot. Why did the Oslo agreement? Why was it a failure? It was political agreement without thinking about the people on the ground. Were they prepared for anything like, do they know what a framework for reconciliation process should look like? Did anybody ever tell them there was such a thing as reconciliation? And so what we wanted to wear like these ants on the ground You know, who are situation to create this framework for a reconciliation process to be an integral part of any political future agreement, because without that, all you can expect is another ceasefire until the next time. And so the combination of nonviolence, but also of people understanding that there will have to be this process of reconciliation, because without that, we have a ceasefire, maybe. Which is good. I mean, Ireland has a ceasefire. They don't really have peace. I'd like to have this ceasefire as well. So it's a combination of both attitudes. And it's allowing the dignity of the other, you know, the night before I went to America. I had assumed, with many of the women, the Palestinian women from the parent circle, I'm very interested in women coming to the table. And I asked them to tell me what their daily life is like in the West Bank. Because people are not looking at the West Bank, they don't realize what's going on there. That's a cornering just waiting to blow up. And each of them told me that they were, they children were stuck at home. Their husbands couldn't go to work. So these are of course domestic violence. Why wouldn't they be And I promised them that wherever I went in America, I would talk about the West Bank and the life that they are leading. And people must know that people must allow and understand what the cyclists are doing, and how dangerous that is, and how we've got to find a way. We've got to find a way to talk, yes, I agree. We must talk to the cyclists.
SPEAKER_00
48:14 - 49:04
One of the things, Ali, that I recently really learned from you, that just, it was about normalization, is really normalization, normalization of Israeli relationships, Saudi Arabia, other countries. And you spoke so powerfully and just, I felt so schooled by the time you were done about real normalization will never happen in the context. of occupation, that the gateway to real normalization is Palestinian and Israeli peace. If you do that work, it sounds like things will fall away and make roads to normalization in many ways. Is that a fair assessment of what I learned?
SPEAKER_02
49:04 - 51:17
Well, this is part of it. I mean, if I think as a responsible Community leader, I will say the following. Israel can have any effort or do successful steps to our normalizations with the Arabs denying the Palestinian file. But this bump will blow up in any event on any table in everywhere. That's number one. Israel can successfully make normalization with Arab governments. but it will not succeed to make normalization with Arabs. With the people. That's number two. Yeah, and this is not the normalization that I am aiming to. Number three, I think we are the best gate for Israel to the Arab world, the Palestinian. any normalization effort has to pass through the Palestinian normal life towards Arabs, because no Arabs will dare to have a serious, deep normalization process with Israel as long as Israel is laying on the Palestinian in Westback and Gaza. Finally, I want to be a part of a dignified solution. This normalization is without dignity, because we live without dignity. And we are the key to the Middle East peace, the Palestinian fight, and the Jewish security as well, not just the Palestinian freedom. And I can understand the deep need for security for Jewish people and Israelis here. But I do believe that the only security for Israeli future is the Palestinian freedom, as I do believe that the Palestinians freedom will not be built on Jewish graves. It will be built through Jewish hearts. And that's why this is the dignified freedom that I want.
SPEAKER_00
51:17 - 52:08
As we're sitting here, talking to one another catastrophic violence is being perpetrated against Palestinians. I mean, like I woke up this morning and just the news, the images, what would you tell me other people here in the US people listening to the podcast? What would you tell us is the most helpful thing we can do? I'm writing to everyone that will listen about, not just a ceasefire, and I learn this too from ULE, a cease conflict, a ceasefire is not enough, a cease conflict. I'm writing, I'm calling. What can we do that's helpful and what are we doing that's absolutely not helpful?
SPEAKER_01
52:08 - 56:15
I think you're importing outcome. And instead of that, you might ask your government to increase the money. These huge amount of sums of money in all peace movements as well, the percentage, that we think there's a decent rule that it's lawful. And without the peace makers, this grace will just be shared by two graves. and stop taking the sides to create. Don't stop saying what is happening. It's very important that people know that they are people living in tents in the salt with guys that are in this terrible weather. And that there are mothers running away with their children. And you know, one of the most poignant pictures that I saw were Palestinian kids holding onto their cats. and that newly broke my heart. You know, it's just, and this wonderful boy who stood on as I saw a clip and he said, I can't go away unless you let me take my cat to the south. And he paid, I don't know, 60 shackles or something, it's family, so that he could take his cat. Think about the mothers and children who are going to think about why. Do you remember when I said, right in the beginning, why? Why do people do these things? Why if you were a kid growing up in Gaza? And every two years there's a law, and you have no shelter, and you're a bomb, and you have no way to run, and you have no freedom of movement, and no hope. What kind of an adult are you going to become? And then I look at the kids, or they were invincible, Because the rockets, I mean, there were thousands of rockets, okay, but they had safe rooms. Unlike the Palestinian mothers and their kids. And now, suddenly after their attack on the city of October, they are in trauma. The whole two nations are in a trauma. And then I think about the kids that living in Steward and Auspherong and Auspherong on the border of Gaza. Those kids had been bombarded with rockets since they were small children and they were getting their beds at the age of 12. So what kind of adults are they going to be? So the work of Ali and Robi is cut out. They are so much to be done to heal these two nations. And I would do anything that I can to be with the families in the South's law and the people in the West Bank of Los Children too. And also many of them have families in Gaza who have been wiped out. And so, you know, what are we doing? How many more people have to die? You know, in the morning when I hear the announcements from the army about the soldiers that are killed, I don't think I'm so full of what? And I see these tiny little square pictures of beautiful kids. What the hell are they doing there? What is the end of this madness? How many more people need to die? How many more? When are the hostages ever going to come home? So who are we going to talk to just the people we like? No. It's got to end. This is mad. I can't bear it. I tell you when I see those pictures and all these people have become just numbers. All the people in Gaza are numbers, but the people in Israel are also numbers. All these people who are killed. For what? What is the end goal? Nobody knows. But one can just hope that people will start to understand that the Palestinians deserve the dignity that they deserve. And these ways that heart, I'd like to idea about the Jewish heart and the Palestinian heart, because I think it's the same heart.
SPEAKER_00
56:15 - 56:30
All that you said in the same interview with Amidara, you said, I believe in one God and that God made both of us, the Israelis and the Palestinians, sounds very much what Robbie is saying right now.
SPEAKER_02
56:30 - 56:56
Yeah, I mean, listen, my call on everyone, not just to stand for a solution but even to work for it. What is happening in Gaza has to stop immediate, immediate. When Israel says, we need to take over Hamas, we need to finish Hamas. It seems like the rest of the Palestinians are... You can't take an idea. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
56:56 - 56:59
You can't. Okay. So what does that look like?
SPEAKER_02
56:59 - 01:00:40
So it seems like the rest, if you take over Hamas, the rest are mandellas. No. As Hamas was created, there will be hundreds and others. Why we deal with the leaves, leaving the roots of the problem. On the other hand, if we Palestinian create threats on Israelis, we're just pushing them to be more aggressive and more, you know, fearful. And I have always said that my real and biggest enemies are not the Jewish people, it's their fear. And this fear can be overcome by Jews themselves, but also we, Palestinian, has an important role for that. We didn't create all the disasters on Jewish people, but we are not able to deal with any disaster because everything is a disaster around us. So what is the world expecting that will happen in Gaza in a few days, few months, few years? Nothing will happen is just more broken hearts and angry people. That's all and this is going to be the only consequences of this continue. So my call on everyone to stop this madness and to focus in this sees conflict. We need a solution. I will not say, find a solution because I have learned, even that I have learned. What does that mean? We need a final agreement. We need something to be committed to because where we can commit ourselves. What we can commit ourselves to? What are we calling people to do after tomorrow? What kind of election that Israel will have? What kind of system and leadership that we will have as policy? Is it Hamas gonna roll everyone or you know, when the election because Hamas was the language to prove that Israel is the only language that Israel understands is force and violence? Is it BB who will succeed after destroying millions life in Gaza to release bodies of Israelis that I hope not? So what are they aiming for? So I believe that we need the work to invest in the process for the solution and not to wait for the agreement to be signed. Just to start doing even small steps underground to create hope and to create commitment. Number two, we need international conference that all their representatives, all the parts of the problem will be, not just an normalization, with Emirates, I want normalization with the Palestinians as well, because I want my relation with my Israeli neighbors to be normal. We want a dignified piece that were not ashamed of. because many activists are hesitating today to speak to their Israeli partners as well, or to represent with them in a public. Because they are afraid of criticism. You are traders, you are normalizers. No, we want something that people can identify with dignity. So all of that will not happen. If we are the people who are here on the ground, will not take the lead, that's it. So that's why if you are a pro Palestine, secure Jewish life, if you are a pro Israel, free Palestinian life, this is how do I see it? I don't see it any different.
SPEAKER_00
01:00:40 - 01:01:21
I'm going to get super practical and people don't talk about this a lot, but I just feel compelled to ask, is it helpful to financially support peacemakers, where peacemaking organizations, where Palestinians and Israelis are working together, like the parent circle family forum, like stand together. Here is that, I mean, we just have all kinds of financial machinery to support war. Do peacemakers have funded systems to wage peace? We have to. I mean, I'm asking, do you need money to build the systems to wage peace? Yes.
SPEAKER_01
01:01:21 - 01:02:53
Can you imagine how many more people we could get to? How much more work we could be doing on the ground? How much more we could create movies? We could create so many things that would change people's idea of who's on the other side. What is the problem we don't know each other? Do you know that when you go into a school, by the way, we've been banned from the schools, by the strumming government, but when you go into schools? A Palestinian under was really talking about their loss and their transformation to a 17-year-old kid. And you were asked the glass from who do you have admitted by the Stingen? It would actually be nobody. And who speaks Arabic, nobody, and who's being overseas, the whole class. So what do you expect? There's a total cutoff which creates fear which creates hatred. And the women's group in the parents circle does a lot of work in the West Bank going to houses. When I go into a household, the Palestinian partner, they look at me in the beginning quite suspiciously. But once I've told my story and once they've realized, you know, that there are other Israelis, because who have they ever met soldiers and say, Why would they think how many different? So it's breaking through this whole madness, so that we begin to know each other and respect each other and we don't have to know each other. It's a side benefit, you know, but we have to respect each other.
SPEAKER_02
01:02:53 - 01:05:15
Yeah, we do need a lot of money, but even more than that, more than that, we need a plan and we need a coalition. Recently, I start working in creating a coalition of organizations. We need also the word, especially the US government, to deal with this issue of competition for resources between organizations. Because the way they do it, they create so much competition over the resources. We need more partnership with the US government, with the US people in a coalition that will apply to people needs, not just to people feelings. We need the Arabs to invest there. We need Arab money because I'm so proud sometimes when I bring Palestinian donors. It makes me so proud. This has to be part of what Israel and the PA are initiating to the Arabs. That as a support of the grassroots efforts, we need that. We need also partnership with the political system. Because if the grassroots and the political system will work toward one vision, it can be achievable. But for this to happen, we need that US pressure, we need the European pressure on both governments and both political leaders. So we need a lot. And this is the time for us also to leave the typical activism and to think strategically about new strategic Activism that will unite all of us that will remove the competition and that will allow also trust because there is also industry in peace building. We need the word to trust where they invest their money by showing the word how successful our efforts are underground by being together and being united. By the end of the day, it's not going to be Robi Damlin or Alia Bawaad or the Peron circle or Tereer who will push for that agreement, but we will help for the agreement, but it has to be a massive national pressure. By the end of the day in Tel Aviv, in Ramallah, in everywhere, for politician to take courageous and painful steps toward peace. It needs a lot. Peace also. It's fear for many Israelis today.
SPEAKER_01
01:05:16 - 01:05:57
also at the fact, the miracle that we are still continuing to work. Because many organizations felt a piece of it. And I think that's an expression of trust that really is talking about. Because all these women who came out of this room with me, the night before I lived for America, said, even though our lives are so difficult, we want to continue to be members of the parents circle. And I'll have 700 families only three have lived from the war. And I think that's a miracle and that it should be supported. The more you support us, the more work we can do.
SPEAKER_00
01:05:57 - 01:07:16
Yeah. I'm going to do my best on my part too. Help people understand what y'all are doing, why I think it's the bravest work I've ever seen. I think Ali, I think what it requires is the big tremendous ask that you're putting on the table to find not humanity in yourself, but humanity in the people that you were taught trained and have actually real reasons to hate. I want to ask a parting question. It's a big question, but it's a clarity question for me. Just as we go, is there any vision moving forward? And I think this is a big thing in the US, and this is a big part of the divisiveness here. Is there any solution, either one of you see moving forward, where seven million Israelis leave, or seven million Palestinians leave, or is every vision that's held for peace moving forward about a vision of I think what you just both described of an environment living together where, unfortunately, the government will have to follow, not lead. But is there a vision in any piece maker on the ground there that the future does not include both Israelis and Palestinians?
SPEAKER_01
01:07:18 - 01:07:52
Look at such a difficult question, but actually it's not such a difficult question because the solution is being there or such a long time. It's just that word he has the bolts to do it. You'll excuse my language. Everybody knows that at some point the settlements will have to be something to spend it. They will have to be swapping of land. We know all of these things. It's been there for so long. You know, but nobody has the courage. That's the word that I was using. Is that courage to do it? And that's what we need.
SPEAKER_02
01:07:52 - 01:08:38
Yeah, and I think we are like a CME twins. We fight every day each other, but we pay the price of ourselves. We are CME, we are so intertwined. You know what? with we both has nowhere else to go. Number two, no one wants us. I'm not sure that the word one the Jewish people or the Arab one the Palestinian. I'm not sure. The history can tell us. Number three, we will fight until the last drop of blood blindly for our existence. If it is by war, believe me, both sides will be defeated. So this, this land will have no people to live on anymore. Not Israelis neither Palestinians.
SPEAKER_00
01:08:38 - 01:09:02
I'm going to leave with this quote. It's a mishmash of what you both said, but I will remember it forever. And I'm going to push it forward. Peace takes courage. War is fueled by rage and anger. and reconciliation requires truth. That's beautiful.
SPEAKER_02
01:09:02 - 01:09:03
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
01:09:03 - 01:09:11
Ali, I'm waiting for the manifesto. As soon as it's done, I see, I see your big smile, but no pressure, but I'm waiting for it.
SPEAKER_02
01:09:11 - 01:09:22
I'm smiling because I'm surrounded as Robbie always said, with so many angels are trying to make this happen, including yourself. Thank you so much for having us.
SPEAKER_00
01:09:22 - 01:09:44
Yeah, I just, I'm going to do my part here to spread this message to try to get it right myself first to find my own humanity and not the easy way. Not the way I like, well, I see it. I love it. But I see it. The people I'm really angry with right now. And you've got my support and I'm in it all the way.
SPEAKER_01
01:09:44 - 01:09:49
Thank you so, so much for this. Thank you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00
01:09:49 - 01:09:50
Thank you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01
01:09:50 - 01:09:52
Thank you. Oh, God. Oh, bye.
SPEAKER_00
01:10:00 - 01:11:15
I hope this was an important conversation for you, is an important conversation for me. All of the information on Ali and Robby, Tahir, how you can learn more about the Parent Circle Family Forum, how you can contribute and support these efforts. All of these are on Bride Brown.com on the episode page for this podcast. I appreciate you listening. I appreciate you creating some expansiveness to learn to reevaluate to challenge ourselves in each other. That's it. I'm grateful. And stay awkward, brave and kind. Unlockiness is produced by Burnet Brown, Education and Research Group. The music is by Carrie Rodriguez and Gina Chavez. Get new episodes as soon as they're published by following unlockiness on your favorite podcast app. We are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more award winning shows at podcast.voxmedia.com.